You don't often notice exactly when things change in a child's life. It's usually gradual, or too subtle to notice. In August Punkin still talked with a lisp and didn't pronounce his F's or S's, but by Thanksgiving he no longer needed an interpreter. At Christmas Auggie wouldn't be left sitting on his own, in February he required a crash pad of pillows all around him, and now he only falls over when he gets really really excited about something (usually something Punkin is doing).
Well one night, a few weeks ago, I'm pretty sure Auggie hit a new milestone. And it's kinda cool and kinda crazy that I just witnessed a change happen quite literally while he lay in my arms. With a bit of a struggle and whole lot of noise, Auggie fell asleep ALL ON HIS OWN. Ok, so a baby falling asleep on his own certainly has different meaning to different parents. In our house, BABY'S DON'T FALL ASLEEP BY THEMSELVES. It's like an unwritten rule that we didn't really choose but one we've come to accept after much resistance on our part. Up until his 3rd birthday (and still sometimes) Punkin required a warm body to snuggle up to as he dozed off and for much of the rest of the night, too. He inevitably finds his way under our covers and jams his toes into someone's back in the wee hours of the morning.
I can barely remember what bed time was like when Punkin was 8+ months old. I know he wasn't swaddled anymore, that he'd grown out of both the reflux wedge and the swing, and I'm pretty sure it was around that time that he was getting walked to sleep about 50-80% of the time. "Walked" as in strapped into the Ergo or a stroller and hauled all over the neighborhood streets until the humming and soft moaning/groaning drifted away and we were sure his eyes were shut. But then of course there was the second hurdle of getting him from outside the house to inside the bedroom, and from inside said-carrier to out and on the bed. If there were an Olympic sport in putting a sleep-resistant toddler to bed, Veggie and I would be gold medal champions. Sadly, there really isn't much pay out for being so stealthy, but that's not why you do the things you do as a parent.
Back then, walking Punkin to sleep was a survival tactic for us. Now, when I think of the prospect of "walking" Auggie to sleep every night and even on many naps, I think....NO. F'ING. WAY. Oh to be the second child.
So thar night, when Auggie didn't sack out at the boob, wanted nothing to do with bouncing or swaying or rocking or back patting, didn't go for the second attempt at nursing, and wasn't showing much promise in the swing, I chose option C. I laid my squirming, kicking, screaming, punching baby down on the bed, curled around him, rubbed his belly (a constantly moving target with all the writhing and kicking that was going on), and waited with him until the kicking slowed down, the screaming quieted and the hands settled in tight little fists. I didn't think it would happen. I didn't think he'd actually "give in" and go to sleep. But the truth is, there was no "giving in" because there was no more battle. I think when he finally realized that I was right there with him, keeping him warm and safe, and when the yawns started interrupting the screams, he knew it was ok to fall asleep there. It was safe, it was cozy, and there was someone there who'd heard his cries.
We've heard stories of kids being "trained" to sleep on their own, to sooth themselves, to be left to scream for hours until they finally fall asleep from exhaustion, who realize after awhile that despite all their screaming no one is coming to get them, no one is coming to tuck them into the covers and kiss them good night one more time. I chose not to "train" my kids, and for a long time we let Punkin run the show, with various nudges here and there. And now, after 3 years of constant adaptations and various routines, he finally falls asleep all on his own (most nights). I just hope we can be as patient for Auggie...
Update: Auggie's gone back to falling asleep nursing....but then waking up every 3 hours ALL NIGHT LONG. We know it's teething (4+ teeth all pushing through at the same time) and it won't last forever. But I can't decide which sleep pattern I'd prefer: crying to sleep in my arms, but sleeping through the night, or peacefully falling asleep in my arms, only to be up all night long crying in pain. The truth is, it doesn't matter what I'd prefer. I'm just his mom; I don't get to choose.